Arena

Which answer is better?

Two models, one test, no names. Your pick feeds the ratings; the names appear after you vote.

Skip this pair

Sealed: spatial reasoning #1

Text

The prompt is sealed. Judge on the title and the grading note.

A
Set up the cube: 3×3×3 small cubes. Two opposite faces are red (say top z=3 and bottom z=1), and the other four faces are blue (x=1, x=3, y=1, y=3). We need small cubes with exactly one red face and exactly one blue face (and no other painted faces, since each painted face is either red or blue, so exactly one red and exactly one blue means exactly two painted faces total). Classify by position: - **Corners (8 cubes):** each has 3 painted faces, so they don't qualify. - **Edge cubes (12 cubes):** each has exactly 2 painted faces. We need one red and one blue. - Edges between a red face (top or bottom) and a blue face (side): these are the vertical... more precisely, the edges where top/bottom meet side faces. There are 8 such edges (4 on top, 4 on bottom), each joining one red face and one blue face. Each contributes 1 cube with one red and one blue face. That gives 8. - The 4 vertical edges join two blue faces (side to side), giving 2 blue faces — not qualifying. - **Face centers (6 cubes):** each has exactly 1 painted face, so they don't qualify. - **Interior (1 cube):** 0 painted faces. Total qualifying cubes: **8**
Answer A
B
**8** The red faces (say top and bottom) each border 4 side faces, giving 8 edges where red meets blue. The middle cube along each such edge touches exactly two faces of the big cube — one red and one blue — so each of these 8 edges yields one small cube with exactly one red and one blue painted face. - Edge-middle cubes on red–blue edges: 8 ✓ - Corners have 3 painted faces (1 red, 2 blue) — don't count. - Edge-middle cubes on blue–blue edges have 2 blue faces — don't count. **Answer: 8**
Answer B

"Both nailed it" is how tests retire: when nearly every judgement says it, the test stopped measuring anything.

Tell us what broke, or what is missing