Arena

Which answer is better?

Two models, one test, no names. Your pick feeds the ratings; the names appear after you vote.

Skip this pair

How many sisters does Alice's brother have?

Text
PromptAlice has 4 brothers and she also has 3 sisters. How many sisters does Alice's brother have?

A good answer: Four: her 3 sisters plus Alice herself.

A
Alice has 3 sisters, so there are 4 girls in the family: Alice and her 3 sisters. Each brother therefore has **4 sisters**.
Answer A
B
**4 sisters.** Alice's brother has the same sisters Alice does, plus Alice herself. That makes 3 + 1 = 4.
Answer B

"Both nailed it" is how tests retire: when nearly every judgement says it, the test stopped measuring anything.

Tell us what broke, or what is missing