Arena: blind judging

Which answer is better?

Same test, two models, no names. The names appear after you pick.

Skip this pair
HTML / canvasWritten Nov 18, 2026

A 3D pelican riding a bicycle (three.js)

Write a single HTML page that shows a 3D pelican riding a bicycle, made with three.js. Load three.js with exactly this tag and nothing else from the network: <script src="https://goodharts.ai/static/vendor/three/r149/three.min.js"></script> (three.js r149, which defines the global THREE; do not use ES module imports or any other library). Build the pelican and the bicycle from three.js geometry, light the scene, fill the window, and slowly orbit the camera around them so they can be seen from every side.

A good answer: A recognisable pelican (long bill, throat pouch) sitting on a bicycle that makes sense in 3D: two wheels, a frame, handlebars, pedals, the feet near the pedals, from every angle as the camera turns.

A
Answer A
B
Answer B

“Both nailed it” is how tests retire: when nearly every judgement says it, the test stopped measuring anything.

Tell us what broke, or what is missing